Comparison of Action Research and Participatory Research

  Action Research Participatory Research
Actors Researchers

Client Systems

Researchers

Client Groups

Established Authorities

Third-Party Funders

Resources and Authority Researchers Provide:

    research expertise

Researchers Provide:

research expertise

political awareness

Client Groups Provide:

sanction

insights

information

Client Groups Provide:

information

energy

insights

Established Authorities Provide:

sanction power

funds and rewards

Third-Party Funders Provide:

funds

protection

Impacts on Phases  
1. Problem Definition Shared by researchers and client systems

Benefits provided to whole system

Resources and sanction from system leaders

Controlled by client group

Benefits provided to client group

Resources received from clients or extracted from system

2. Data Collection and Analysis Collaborative with whole system

Iteration to system-wide shared diagnosis

Collaborative with clients; adversarial with authorities

Iteration to educate and mobilize client groups

3. Uses of Results Systematic consensus on goals of intervention

Problem solving with systemic benefits

Client consensus on goals of intervention

Negotiations to improve client situation

Source: Brown, D. and Tandon, R. (1983). Ideology and political economy in inquiry: Action research and participatory research. The Journal of Applied Behavioral Science, 19, 277-294.